The Easiest Way to Choose Between Renting and Buying

Weighing Up the Numbers in Bennett Springs

Bennett Springs sits in a price bracket where the decision between renting and buying often comes down to upfront costs and loan serviceability rather than long-term value alone. Properties in the suburb typically fall within the $850,000 price cap for the Australian Government 5% Deposit Scheme, which means first home buyers can access Housing Australia's guarantee without paying Lenders Mortgage Insurance. For buyers who qualify, this removes one of the most significant barriers to ownership. However, rental properties in the area remain in reasonable supply, and the weekly cost of renting a three-bedroom home can be lower than the equivalent mortgage repayment, especially when rates rise.

The question is not which option is inherently superior, but which aligns with your financial position, your employment stability, and how long you intend to stay in the northern suburbs.

How Home Loan Repayments Compare to Rent

A mortgage requires serviceability assessment at an interest rate at least 3.0 percentage points above the loan product rate, meaning lenders test your ability to service the loan at a higher rate than you'll initially pay. In practical terms, this means a borrower applying for a variable rate home loan must demonstrate they can afford repayments even if rates increase. Rent, by contrast, does not involve this forward-looking buffer, and tenants are not assessed on their ability to manage rent increases over the life of a lease.

Consider a buyer in Bennett Springs with a household income of $95,000 per year. They have saved a 5% deposit and qualify for the Australian Government 5% Deposit Scheme. At current variable rates, their fortnightly repayments on a principal and interest loan would exceed what they currently pay in rent by several hundred dollars. However, the buyer is building equity from the first repayment, whereas rent delivers no ownership stake. Over a decade, the cumulative difference in wealth between the two positions can be significant, provided the buyer remains employed and the property holds or increases in value.

Fixed Rate, Variable Rate, or Split Loan Structures

Fixed rate, variable rate and split loan structures may be available depending on the participating lender under schemes like the Australian Government 5% Deposit Scheme. A fixed interest rate home loan locks in repayments for a set period, typically one to five years, which can provide certainty during the early years of ownership. A variable rate loan fluctuates with market conditions, meaning repayments can rise or fall over time. A split loan combines both structures, allowing borrowers to protect part of their loan from rate increases while retaining flexibility on the remainder.

For renters comparing costs, the fixed rate option can make budgeting more predictable, similar to a lease agreement. However, fixed loans typically come with restrictions on additional repayments and may incur break costs if you need to refinance or sell before the fixed period ends. Variable rate loans offer more flexibility, including access to features like an offset account, which can reduce the interest charged on the loan by using savings to offset the balance.

The Impact of Upfront Costs on the Decision

Buyers often underestimate the upfront costs involved in purchasing a home. Beyond the deposit, there are legal fees, building and pest inspections, lender application fees, and in Western Australia, transfer duty. From 7 May 2026, the geographic distinction between the Perth Metropolitan and Peel regions and areas outside those regions was removed for the First Home Owner Rate of duty, and a single statewide threshold now applies to all WA transactions regardless of location. For first home buyers in Bennett Springs, no duty is payable on homes valued up to $600,000, and a concessional rate applies on homes valued between $600,001 and $800,000.

For renters, upfront costs are limited to a bond, usually equivalent to four weeks' rent, and the first month's rent in advance. This lower entry cost means renters can preserve their savings or direct them toward other investments, such as shares or managed funds. However, those savings do not contribute to ownership of an appreciating asset, and rent paid over a decade does not build equity.

In our experience, buyers who delay purchase to save a larger deposit often find that property values increase faster than their ability to save, particularly in suburbs close to established transport corridors like Bennett Springs.

What Happens When You Need to Move

Ownership introduces friction when relocation becomes necessary. Selling a property involves agent fees, legal costs, and potentially capital gains tax if the property was not your principal place of residence. For investors in new builds, both the existing 50 per cent discount and the new indexation and minimum tax arrangements are available as a choice at the time of disposal, but this flexibility does not extend to established homes purchased after certain dates. Renting, by contrast, allows you to end a lease with notice and move without incurring sale costs.

For buyers using an owner occupied home loan, portability is a feature worth considering. A portable loan allows you to transfer your existing loan to a new property without paying discharge fees or reapplying from scratch. Not all lenders offer this feature, and not all loan products within a lender's range include it, so it should be discussed during the application process.

If you're considering purchasing in Bennett Springs but anticipate relocating within five years, the transaction costs of buying and selling may outweigh the equity you build during that period, particularly if property values remain flat or decline.

Government Schemes and Their Effect on Affordability

The Australian Government 5% Deposit Scheme has been operative from 1 October 2025 and is administered by Housing Australia. Eligible first home buyers can purchase with a deposit of as little as 5% of the property value. Housing Australia provides a guarantee to the participating lender of up to 15% of the property value, enabling borrowers to reach a combined deposit and guarantee of 20% without paying LMI. This removes a cost that can range from several thousand to tens of thousands of dollars, depending on the loan amount and loan to value ratio.

No income caps apply, and no annual place limits apply to the scheme as it currently operates. This is a departure from earlier iterations of government assistance, which imposed strict income thresholds and capped the number of participants each year. For buyers in Bennett Springs, this means access is determined by eligibility criteria and lender appetite rather than competition for limited places.

Renters who qualify for the scheme may find that the gap between rental costs and mortgage repayments narrows once LMI is removed from the equation. However, the scheme requires participation from a panel lender, and not all lenders offer the same range of loan products or interest rate discounts. Comparing loan options across the panel is essential to securing a competitive outcome.

Interest Only Loans and Their Role in the Comparison

Interest only loans are more common among investors than owner-occupiers, but they occasionally appear in discussions about affordability. An interest only loan allows the borrower to pay only the interest component for a set period, typically one to five years, after which the loan reverts to principal and interest repayments. The monthly repayment during the interest only period is lower than a principal and interest loan, which can make the property more affordable in the short term.

However, interest only loans do not build equity through repayments. The loan balance remains unchanged throughout the interest only period, meaning the borrower is not progressing toward ownership in the same way a principal and interest loan does. For renters comparing the two, an interest only loan delivers a cost structure closer to renting, with the added benefit of capital growth if property values rise, but without the wealth-building mechanism of paying down debt.

A long-term interest-only residential loan is classified as non-standard where the LVR is greater than 80 per cent and the contractual interest-only period is greater than five years or is not specified, which affects how lenders assess risk and price the loan. For most buyers in Bennett Springs, a principal and interest loan remains the more appropriate structure for achieving long-term financial stability.

Building Equity Versus Preserving Flexibility

Ownership builds equity in two ways: through principal repayments and through capital growth. Each mortgage repayment reduces the amount owed and increases the borrower's stake in the property. If property values rise, the borrower benefits from both sources of equity. If values fall, the borrower may find themselves in a position where the outstanding loan exceeds the property's value, known as negative equity.

Renting preserves flexibility but forgoes both forms of equity. A tenant can relocate without selling, can avoid exposure to property market downturns, and is not responsible for maintenance or council rates. However, a tenant does not benefit from capital growth, and rental payments do not reduce any debt or build ownership.

For buyers with stable employment and a long-term outlook, the trade-off favours ownership. For those in casual or contract roles, or those anticipating interstate relocation, the flexibility of renting may outweigh the benefits of equity.

Call one of our team or book an appointment at a time that works for you. We work with clients across Bennett Springs, Ellenbrook, Beechboro, and surrounding areas, and can walk you through home loan options tailored to your circumstances, whether you're a first home buyer or looking to refinance an existing loan.

Frequently Asked Questions